Motor Vehicle Insurance: Know What You are Paying For

A vehicle is often one of the biggest investments a person will make, but a single accident, theft or unexpected mechanical failure can turn that investment into a financial nightmare. The Non-life Insurance Division of the National Financial Ombud Scheme (NFO) would like consumers to understand that not all motor vehicle insurance policies offer the same protection. While motor vehicle insurance offers a measure of protection, choosing the wrong cover could leave you exposed to costs you thought were insured.

“Understanding the different types of cover available is, therefore, essential for vehicle owners to make informed decisions, protect their assets and avoid unpleasant surprises when submitting a claim,” said Edite Teixeira-McKinon, Lead Ombud of the Non-life Insurance Division.

In South Africa, the following types of motor vehicle insurance are available:

– Comprehensive cover: This is generally required by the financier or bank when a vehicle is purchased through financing. It typically covers accidental damage, hail damage, fire, theft and third-party liability, subject to the terms and conditions of the policy.

– Third-party cover: This provides cover for liability arising from damage caused to another person’s property. Depending on the policy, it may also include protection against fire and theft of the insured vehicle. It does not cover damage to your own vehicle resulting from an accident.

– Top-up cover: If a financed vehicle is written off following extensive damage or is stolen and not recovered, the amount paid out by the underlying insurer may be less than the outstanding balance owed to the financier. Top-up cover is designed to cover this shortfall, subject to the policy’s terms and limits.

– Mechanical breakdown cover: This is particularly relevant to older vehicles and provides cover for the mechanical or electrical failure of specified vehicle components, as set out in the policy.

– Tyre and rim cover: This covers specified damage to a vehicle’s tyres and rims, subject to the policy conditions.

– Scratch and dent cover: This provides cover for minor cosmetic damage, such as small dents and scratches, in accordance with the policy’s terms and conditions.

Edite Teixeira-McKinon said as a high value asset which is constantly depreciating both in financial terms and due to wear and tear, the type of cover selected by the consumer must consider whether the vehicle is financed and the age of the vehicle.

She said the importance of noting the differences between the various types of cover was highlighted in a matter dealt with by the division where the complainant submitted a claim for accident damage to his truck. During the validation of the claim, the insurer noted that the damage claimed arose from mechanical breakdown which was specifically excluded from cover under his comprehensive policy. There was no evidence of accident damage to the truck and the insurer’s rejection of the claim was upheld.

“Another common misconception is regarding how a claimant is indemnified following an incident. Most policies give the insurer the sole election to determine whether the vehicle will be repaired or written off. This election, however, must be exercised reasonably and the insurer often relies on an assessor’s findings when making this decision,” Edite Teixeira-McKinon said.

Her office recently dealt with a matter where a claim was submitted to the insurer for damage sustained to the insured vehicle following the theft and recovery of the vehicle. The complainant was not happy with the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle as he argued that the vehicle’s value had depreciated following the recovery of the vehicle. The insurer correctly pointed out that the policy did not provide cover for depreciation of the vehicle’s value.

Having regard to the assessor’s report, the retail value of the vehicle at the time of the loss, and the vehicle’s repair costs, the Non-life Insurance Division agreed with the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle.

Edite Teixeira-McKinon said another common type of complaint was complainants being unhappy with the insurer’s election to write off a vehicle following an incident instead of repairing it. This is especially the case with older vehicles and vehicles that have been paid for in full and are not financed.

“The risk of driving an older vehicle lies in the increasing cost of the parts due to a lack of availability which leads to an increase in the likelihood of the vehicle being declared uneconomical to repair following an incident.

“On the other hand, affordability becomes an issue for complainants when having to replace a vehicle that has been written off and hence the resistance to this approach by some complainants,” she said.

Complaints in respect of top-up policies mostly regarded the settlement amount. These policies are specific about how the insurer’s liability is calculated in the event of a claim and the settlement amount usually excludes balloon payments; any missed monthly instalments; excesses which were deducted from the underlying insurer’s settlement; accessories which were not specified on the underlying policy; and premium payments on any other policy which is being paid from the finance account.

Similarly, mechanical breakdown policies are also very specific about what components are covered, and the limit of the insurer’s liability is dependent on the component which has failed.

The insurer’s discretion regarding how the complainant is indemnified following a motor vehicle claim was recently dealt with by the NFO where the complaint went all the way to the independent Appeal Tribunal.

The complainant submitted a claim for damage to his vehicle which arose when a third-party spray-painted his vehicle. The assessor inspected the vehicle and deemed the vehicle to be uneconomical to repair as the vehicle’s repair costs amounted to R468 175.00, while the retail value at the time of the loss was R596 300.00, which meant that the cost of repairs exceeded the insurer’s write-off threshold. The complainant was unhappy with the insurer’s decision and in his application for assistance to the NFO, he requested that the NFO declare invalid the insurer’s decision to write off the vehicle and that the insurer be directed to make a cash payment for the cost of repairs as quoted for by the complainant’s own service provider.

The insurer advised that when the complainant disagreed with its decision to write the vehicle off, the complainant was given a further two options regarding the settlement of the claim. The second option was for the insurer to repair the vehicle at a repairer of its choice, and the third option was for the complainant to retain the salvage and repair the vehicle himself. The insured declined to accept any of the options proposed by the insurer. The Non-life Insurance Division issued a final ruling upholding the various options made by the insurer to the insured. The insured then lodged an application for leave to appeal the final ruling.

“The Appeal Tribunal agreed that the policy granted the insurer a discretion to decide the manner in which the complainant was to be indemnified in the event of a loss, including the insurer’s decision to repair the vehicle at a repairer of its choice, and it dismissed the insured’s application for leave to appeal the final ruling.

“The complainant then accepted the insurer’s cash offer for the complainant to repair the vehicle at his own repairer.

“The matter highlights the importance of understanding the terms of an insurance policy and recognising that the insurer may have the contractual right to determine how a claim is settled,” Edite Teixeira-McKinon added.

Related Articles

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

- Advertisement -spot_img

Latest Articles